Nomadics

Meanderings & mawqifs of poetry, poetics, translations y mas. Travelogue too.

Nomadics header image 2

Freud for All

January 2nd, 2010 · 1 Comment · Cultural Studies, Essays, Literature, Translation

Since yesterday, the works of Sigmund Freud have entered the public domain — I am not sure that the publishing world is in a feeding frenzy over here in Anglosaxonia, though in France, Libération made a big spiel about the fact that now there are at least 2 French versions of Totem and Taboo, 3 of Civilization and its Discontents (at least one of which uses “Culture” rather than “Civ.”), and 2 Interpretations of Dreams. This could however also become an interesting moment for Freud in English where the old James Strachey supervised translations for the  Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud still hold sway. (See details on this edition, its organization & translators here). There is certainly something to be said for new translations of a number of core texts in the Freud canon, despite the obvious difficulties that revising what has become standard psychoanalytical terminology would entail. Useful to remember that Alix Strachey’s New German-English psychoanalytical vocabulary came out in 1943. In this case a new translation could in fact mean a new theory because here more than elsewhere in so-called science,  “les mots” do not adhere to “les choses” but rather create “les choses” as concepts. A major 21st century translation project? Or simply an antiquarian’s delight?

Tags: ··

One Comment so far ↓

  • Alan Sondheim

    Antiquarian’s delight; Freud, Lacan, etc. – proponents of metapsychology – all of this is going to appear increasingly outdated in relation to cog sci; on the other hand, Freudian/Lacanian terminology (as well as Buddhist terminology) will always be useful for descriptions of subjective phenomenology/psychology; it’s just that the ontological bases are all wrong.

Leave a Comment

Locations of visitors to this page